Insights

Article

The True Cost of Modular vs. Stick-Built: A Pro Forma Comparison That Doesn't Lie

"Modular is cheaper." "Modular is more expensive." Both statements are wrong as stated. Cost competitiveness depends on project type, scale, market, and how you account for schedule.

Seven Cost Categories

Factory and structure cost is often higher per square foot than stick-built framing for small projects and approaches parity at 20 or more units. Site work and foundation runs slightly more expensive due to precision tolerances required for module placement.

Transportation and set costs $3 to $8 per loaded mile per module plus crane, totaling $80,000 to $200,000 for a 20 unit project with no stick-built equivalent. This is a net-new cost category that does not exist in conventional construction.

![Pro forma comparison spreadsheet](https://yyjfntvzblexehejwjbm.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/pro-forma-analysis.jpg)

Button-up and finish, covering marriage walls, module joints, and MEP connections, typically runs 15% to 25% of total hard costs. This work requires specialized knowledge and is where inexperienced GCs create cost overruns. Soft costs should be budgeted at 15% to 20% for modular versus 12% to 15% for stick-built, reflecting the additional coordination and factory management overhead.

> Six months of schedule compression on a $4,000,000 loan at 8% equals $160,000 in carrying cost savings.

Where the Math Shifts

On a 20 unit California project at $250 per square foot, modular runs approximately $5,520,000 net after schedule savings. Stick-built runs approximately $4,590,000. At this scale, the schedule saving only partially offsets the gap.

The math shifts at 50 or more units where factory overhead amortizes and transport cost per unit decreases. High-cost labor markets where framing crews command $85 or more per hour move the comparison further. Projects with repetitive unit types see the greatest factory efficiency gains because production line setup costs are spread across more units.

The Pro Forma Decision

Build both pro formas before you decide. Include schedule-adjusted carrying costs, not just hard cost comparisons. Factor in the risk-adjusted cost of schedule uncertainty, which is historically higher for stick-built in high-demand labor markets.

The answer is always project-specific. Any vendor or consultant who gives you a definitive answer without running your numbers is not worth hiring.